Van Persie or Rooney?

**superally** · 00:11, 29th Dec 2011, 00:11

which one would you have in your team and why? ( am asking cos its time of year to pick your world X1, and i confused)

**itownvillan** · 01:15, 29th Dec 2011, 01:15

Originally Posted by superally

which one would you have in your team and why? ( am asking cos its time of year to pick your world X1, and i confused)

when fit, Van Persie. world class. only problem is he has a bad track record with injuries.

**B6.82** · 01:57, 29th Dec 2011, 01:57

Van Persie, he is better than Rooney and can score against the bigger clubs..

**Paul** · 02:27, 29th Dec 2011, 02:27

Rooney. Adds a lot more than just goals. Better player.

**MrWoodySir** · 08:04, 29th Dec 2011, 08:04

Originally Posted by Paul

Rooney. Adds a lot more than just goals. Better player.

United fan i guess...

RVP is a far better player.....

**Darren** · 12:45, 29th Dec 2011, 12:45

Originally Posted by woodysharp

United fan i guess...

RVP is a far better player.....

Yes I tend to agree.

**Vidic** · 13:17, 29th Dec 2011, 13:17

Originally Posted by superally

which one would you have in your team and why? ( am asking cos its time of year to pick your world X1, and i confused)

Why can't you have both?

Originally Posted by B6.82

can score against the bigger clubs..

Eh?

**Darren** · 13:28, 29th Dec 2011, 13:28

I was confused too, but I think it should say can't score against the big clubs. Not at all sure if that applies to either of them though to be honest.

**Vidic** · 13:32, 29th Dec 2011, 13:32

Originally Posted by Darren

I was confused too, but I think it should say can't score against the big clubs. Not at all sure if that applies to either of them though to be honest.

Rooney's scored in CL semis and the final, has scored plenty v Arsenal, City and Chelsea in his time. The only big team he struggles is Liverpool (if they count...) and for England has scored in the Euros albeit hasn't done much else since. Anyway I'm not gonna get involved in another Rooney debate again, I've made my opinions clear in a few threads.

**Darren** · 13:36, 29th Dec 2011, 13:36

Originally Posted by Vidic

Rooney's scored in CL semis and the final, has scored plenty v Arsenal, City and Chelsea in his time. The only big team he struggles is Liverpool (if they count...) and for England has scored in the Euros albeit hasn't done much else since. Anyway I'm not gonna get involved in another Rooney debate again, I've made my opinions clear in a few threads.

Yes you're right he has, and I am certainly not going to say that he's not a big time player because he obviously is. My opinion though (for what it's worth) is that RVP is actually the better player.

**MrWoodySir** · 13:38, 29th Dec 2011, 13:38

I thought RVP been better than Rooney went without saying tbh.

**Norn_irish_stu** · 14:23, 29th Dec 2011, 14:23

RVP better player yes RVP has injury problems but rooney will get sent off god knows how many times just because he is a fucking idiot.

**B6.82** · 14:56, 29th Dec 2011, 14:56

Rooneys last goals after a drought since September, Wolves, QPR, Fulham, enough said..

**Darren** · 15:22, 29th Dec 2011, 15:22

Originally Posted by B6.82

Rooneys last goals after a drought since September, Wolves, QPR, Fulham, enough said..

What about all the goals he's scored in big games before that though?

**B6.82** · 15:59, 29th Dec 2011, 15:59

What big games?..

Thread: Van Persie or Rooney?

Thread Tools

Display

Van Persie or Rooney?

Posting Permissions